"It looks bad.
We have to hurry if we we still want to see something.
Everything disappears."
Paul Cézanne
My impression of Kolkata is like a
collection of microcosms which stand beside each other, sometimes a change to "another world" begins in Kolkata in the next street. Anjan Dutt´s film takes place
in a small quarter called “Bow Barracks”, once a caserne for
American soldiers during World war II is now a residence for
Anglo-Indians. Like it happened and still happens in all big cities –
speculators are looking for grounds on which shopping malls and a lot
more nonsense can be built. The historic value of this place or the
Bow Barracks as an cultural heritage means nothing for this
adventurers on the search for quick earned money.
I think it was Martin Scorsese who once
said that cinema tells very often about a part of the world which is
gone. Cinema as a reflection of an almost lost world (or in the world which is going to disappear) is something
like a “Leitmotiv” in film history, in this case a film as a
witness of something disappearing.
At the beginning the first people move
already out. The people who are still staying are split in a group
who wants to go to Australia or England and the ones who insist on
staying “with their property”.
The
buildings carry signs of decay. Corridors look like infected by
greenish mold. But one building is painted in a shining red, like it
is resisting the decay and and the rapidly changing world. The human
pendant to this building is Peter called “the cheater”, a living memory of the history of this building. He is also something like a "Conférencier" and almost the hub where all these different individual life stories
are congregated. These different individual stories are composed to a
network of different human lives.
The
film tells rather a collection of stories which happen isochronic and
which overlay each other.
There
is Tom, the smuggler who is always beating his young wife Anne.
Bradley one of the two sons of Emily loves her. His elder brother
lives in London and we see often Emily phoning from an Std. Booth his
son, but reaches only his answer machine. Sally, a girl from the
neighborhood is in love with Brad, but he can´t answer her feelings.
Another Neighbor, Rosa cheats on her husband with an insurance agent
and wants to leave as well the Bow Barracks. Her husband Melville
wants to stay, to stay “with his property”. Not only the many
characters in this film are interacting with each other, the tension
between the change and preservation gives this film a strange nervous
energy.
Relatively
late the titles appear with a song by Anjan Dutt, a song which tells
already about memories of this place, “where stories are
told and songs are sung” which reminds us again in the transience of this part of the world but as
well in the cultural, social context of this special community.
Finally
Bow Barracks forever tells about past and present of this quarter at
the same time. Maybe Cinema is the best example for explaining the
speed of light. And astronomer explains to Patricio Guzman in his film
Nostalgia de la luz (Nostalghia for the Light) that according to
light speed everything what we see is already past.
The
narrative element of this “comédie dramatique” is evoking once
the now and here of the characters and in the next moment all these
biographies seem to be already history.
Bradley
plays in a Rock´n Roll band and one performance is extended to a
musical element (music by Neel Dutt). The time and especially the
gravitation field of the plot is for a moment suspended. That
happens with the title song (sung by Anjan Dutt and later by Sally)
at the beginning and the end as well.
At
the same time the film is witnessing an endangered place with all the
people who are connected or disconnected with it. But it is also
nearly exploding with life and emotions, violence, love, solidarity,
tenderness.This “explosion of life" is again a kind of resistance
against not only the decay of the buildings but also the decay of a
cultural heritage of a community.
Another
magical element in this film is the appearances, disappearances and
reappearances of the many characters. Even though Anjan Dutts
cinematic temperament seems to me closer to John Cassavetes than to
Yasujiro Ozu, the film is righteous to each single character in an
almost Ozu-like kind. All of them have their moment when they can
shine for a while. Bradley in his Rock´n Roll performance, the
stubborn Emily who decides at the end to accept the Bow Barracks as
her home, Sally´s performance of the “Bow Barracks song” at the
end in which she seemed to transform all her unanswered feelings for
Bradley. Rosa finally returns to her husband for a reconciliation.
Bradley
will be shot in his leg when he tries to defend Anne against his
violent husband. There is a small and wonderful moment when we see in
Tom´s face the sign of resignation and the realization of his own
failed life. Even this most dislike able character has at least his own moment, a moment which escapes our judgement.
The
end has a strange contrast. At the first sight it looks like a happy
ending. Brad finally can marry Anne who is divorced from her violent
husband and Emily will now accept Anne as her new daughter in law.
Even a small tender scene between Emily and Peter give hints to a
happier life. Despite all obstacles the community seems to have found
new courage to stay, to renovate the buildings. But just after
Sally´s interpretation
of
the “Bow Barracks”-song, titles are reminding us in the still
endangered condition of the buildings. The decay and the slow dying
of a social-cultural heritage goes on.
Despite
this happy ending, there remains a strange melancholy in me. The Bow
Barracks, the people who lived there and finally this film. A film is
in itself like a building endangered by a likely decay of its
chemical matter and as mortal than human memories depending on the
matter of a living body. The bitter sweet after taste I know since I
love Cinema will sty in my mind..
This
was the first film I saw by Anjan Dutt as a director (three other
films I ordered on DVD are waiting for being watched). I learned he
is famous as a musician and song writer. Until know I knew him only
as an actor, one of these charismatic faces you see often if you are
half-way familiar with Indian art cinema, especially Bengali Cinema.
Well,
Bow Barracks foreverr and Anjan Dutt is one of the lucky discoveries
I made during my last India journey. I am looking forward to see more
films by him.
Rüdiger
Tomczak.
A text on ranjana ami ar ashbo na can be read here.
No comments:
Post a Comment